That's a tough question. My taste in men changes with my mood, but I see your point: both my daughters and their friends (teenagers) like Legolas. I guess my favourite, just by a hair, would be that airhead Took! For brains I would go with the older man. Yes, Gandalf! If I were young I might prefer Frodo. Who was the other human? I've forgotten his name. The one who weakened and tried to get the ring? I like him as well.